Why Bill C-39 Makes Canada Weaker, Not Stronger

The Government of Canada calls Bill C-39 the “Building Canada Strong Act” — but the Act would undermine key environmental laws designed to protect at-risk species and ecosystems

Kristen Weiss

The Government of Canada is rushing to push forward Bill C-39, the “Building Canada Strong” Act, despite growing opposition across many sectors. First Nations, scientists, lawyers, politicians, environmentalists and labour unions are among those publicly expressing concern about the Act’s sweeping changes to Canada’s environmental, trade, and labour laws that would accelerate major infrastructure approvals and weaken environmental laws meant to protect wildlife and ecosystems.

The federal government says the legislation will help strengthen Canada’s economy by speeding up approvals for major industrial projects, attracting investment, and creating jobs. However, many experts argue that short term economic growth is being prioritized at the expense of environmental protection, Indigenous rights, public accountability, and long term economic stability.

Experts Sounding the Alarm

On October 22, 2026, 56 Fellows of the Royal Society of Canada signed an open letter warning that Bill C-39 could cause serious and potentially irreversible environmental damage. They argued that shorter assessment timelines could prevent experts from fully investigating environmental impacts or identifying less harmful alternatives. The scientists recommended removing or amending several clauses of the bill, including the ability to extend project fast-tracking indefinitely.

Pacific Wild joins a long list of environmental organizations who oppose Bill C-39, including Greenpeace Canada, West Coast Environmental Law, Ecojustice, Environmental Defence, the David Suzuki Foundation, Équiterre, and Georgia Strait Alliance.

Beyond their concerns about wildlife and habitat protection, these groups warn that the bill would reduce independent oversight of major industrial projects, including pipelines and nuclear developments; expand ministerial authority to override environmental considerations; and could allow large areas to be designated for accelerated industrial development. Several organizations have called for the bill to be examined by multiple specialized parliamentary committees rather than a single committee.

Fast-Tracking — At What Cost?

Now is the time to make your voice heard!

Bill C-39, tabled in September 2026, would build on Bill C-5, a 2025 law that let the federal cabinet exempt certain major projects from existing laws if it judged them to be in the “national interest.”  TheIntroduced on September 21, 2026, the Act is currently being reviewed by the Legislative Committee on Bill C-39 in the House of Commons. Clause-by-clause amendments of the bill beganbegin on November 16, 2026 (there are more than 300 clauses!). Simultaneously, the Senate is conducting a “pre-study” of the bill- to examine the bill’s subject matter before it passes the House of Commons.

As review gets underway, Liberal, Conservative, and Green MPs have all called for changes to various clauses that would remove environmental oversight, reduce Indigenous consultation requirements, and give Cabinet unilateral decision-making powers for some large-scale projects. However, according to Isabel McMurray, a lawyer with Ecojustice, “Any amendments being passed right now are small attempts at harm reduction that won’t change the balance of harms that the bill proposes.”

Under clause 177, ministers would have to consider the “technical, economic and practical feasibility” of conditions placed on certain Species at Risk Act permits. This could result in weaker environmental safeguards when conservation measures are considered too expensive. 

Clause 101 would allow the Minister of the Environment to change or even remove existing approval requirements for projects deemed nationally significant, even if the project would create significant adverse effects to the environment. For example, protections could be weakened for endangered Southern Resident killer whales to make way for B.C.’s Roberts Bank Terminal 2 expansion.

Killer Whales pass shipping traffic

 Clause 103 would allow the Cabinet to establish “Regions of National Interest,” within which eligible projects (including pipelines, energy infrastructure, and industrial activities) could receive blanket approvals without having to obtain standard federal permits. This means that once an area is designated as a “region of national interest,” environmental impact assessments and other regulatory reviews might not be required for individual projects, regardless of their potential to cause environmental damage. No limits have been specified on the potential size of these regions or the projects they may include. 

Regional assessments are already underway in three proposed “regions of national interest”: the Ring of Fire Area in northern Ontario, the St. Lawrence River Area in Quebec, and the Canada-Nova Scotia Offshore Area for oil and gas exploratory drilling.

Equally troubling is Clause 5, which would allow certain construction activities to commence on projects deemed to be “in the public interest” before completing environmental impact assessments — yet the bill provides no definition of what constitutes “public interest”. Activities like land clearing, dredging, and road building could cause irreversible damage before a project’s environmental impacts are understood.

There are several other problematic elements of Bill C-39:

  • Clause 98 would remove the five-year expiry date on the ability to fast-track projects established under Bill C-5, allowing this power to continue indefinitely. 
  • Clause 99 removes the requirement to make the list of all national interest projects available to the public. 
  • Clause 189 would amend the Fisheries Act to allow regulations under which developers could “pay a fee…to offset the harmful effects” of certain activities on fish or their habitats, rather than directly restoring damaged habitat. It does not require these payments to fully compensate for ecological damage.
  • Clause 2 requires impact assessments of designated projects to be completed within one year, including consultations with impacted Indigenous groups.

Under Canadian law, a decision made following inadequate consultation with Indigenous Peoples is not in the “public interest.” The Supreme Court of Canada, in Clyde River (Hamlet) v. Petroleum Gro-Services Inc. (2017) held that “a project authorization that breaches the constitutionally protected rights of Indigenous peoples cannot serve the public interest” (paras 39 and 40).

Already, 12 First Nations groups are challenging in Federal Court the government’s decision to designate the Pacific Link Pipeline as a “national interest project” on the grounds that they were inadequately consulted. 

The Assembly of First Nations (AFN), the B.C. Assembly of First Nations, the Chiefs of Ontario, the Nishnawbe Aski Nation, and the Iroquois Caucus are among those calling for Bill C-39’s withdrawal. They assert that accelerated approvals could undermine free, prior and informed consent (FPIC), which is not explicitly referenced in the bill. One-year federal review timelines may be insufficient for communities to assess proposed developments, seek technical advice, and make decisions according to their own governance processes. The Indigenous Centre for Cumulative Effects also warns that regional pre-approvals could overlook the combined impacts of industrial activities across Indigenous territories.

Representatives from the NDP, Green Party, and Bloc Québécois are opposing Bill C-39 because they argue it would concentrate too much power in Cabinet and individual ministers while weakening democratic oversight. They also criticize the rushed parliamentary review of the legislation.

The Canadian Labour Congress, CUPE, and other labour unions oppose changes to the Canada Labour Code that would allow greater government intervention in strikes. They warn that employers may be less willing to negotiate fair agreements if they expect the government to intervene and end labour disputes.

What it comes down to is that Bill C-39 claims to “build Canada strong,” but it aims to do so by undermining the very safeguards meant to protect Canada’s air, water, soil, wildlife, and wild places. A federal act that fast-tracks industrial activity at the expense of natural resources, public health, and biodiversity does not create a strong country in the long-term. Instead, it sets the stage for environmental destruction and an erosion of public trust.

Additional Public Health and Environmental Risks from Bill C-30

A similar fight is playing out over food. Bill C-30, a budget omnibus bill, changed the Pest Control Products Act, and the law now says the health minister can weigh national economic security, regional economic security or national food security when deciding whether a pesticide stays on the market. Public interest groups argue this lets Cabinet authorize pesticides despite unacceptable risks, a departure from science-based decision-making. 

Experts also object to how it happened: the bill made the biggest changes to pesticide regulation in a generation, yet agriculture, health and environment committees never studied it. Senator Rosa Galvez, an expert in pollution control, said the pesticide provisions deserved their own legislative process and a full study. Scientists and advocates warn of real consequences: some pesticides have caused cancer, cognitive impacts and reproductive toxicity, and agricultural workers face the greatest exposure. There is an economic risk too, since the European Union bans pesticides still used in Canada and is Canada’s third-largest agricultural market. 

Call and email your Member of Parliament, write a Letter to the Editor, and share about C-39 publicly (tag your MP and other leaders on socials!).

Want more info? Read our letter to the Legislative Committee on Bill C-39, and get help writing your letter from the Georgia Strait Alliance and the David Suzuki Foundation. 

Submit a letter opposing C-30 with help from Nature Canada.